|
|
A Conversation
A Roman Catholic and A Protestant Conversation
The Nature of Authority in the Church
|
The follow conversation is between Roman Catholic Apologist John Martignoni and non-denominational Christian Pastor Edward Walker III. I will do my best to present each of their comments in their proper context and in the correct order. I will use purple to highlight the person responding on the other person and red for the person being responding to and green for comments previously made. I will help by highlighting each persons name initially to show which one is talking.
|
|
Follow the Discussion Below
- The Beginning
Edward Walker wrote to Mr. A. Martinez about the differences between Roman Catholics and Protestants. There was a wonderful exchange between Mr. Walker and Mr. A. Martinez. Mr. A. Martinez brought in Mr. John Martignoni to help him further the conversation. Below is the last e-mail sent to Mr. A. Martinez from Mr. Walker before Mr. Martignoni joined in the conversation. Read More >>> - The First Response - Mr. Walker
In this first response, sent to Mr. John Martignoni on August 3, 2008, Mr. Walker includes his comments in the e-mail where Mr. Martignoni responded to Mr. Walker's e-mail to Mr. A. Martinez. Read More >>> - The Second Response - Mr. Martignoni
Here is Mr. Martignoni's response to Mr. Walker's previous comments. At this point in the conversation Mr. Martignoni directly responded to Mr. Walker rather that use the comment/strategies method used before. In order to keep the context you may have to go back to the previous conversation. Read More >>> - The Third Response - Mr. Walker - Part One
Here Mr. Walker responds to Mr. Martignoni's previous e-mail. Mr. Walker includes the entire e-mail message and responds to each section. Read More >>> - The Third Response - Mr. Walker - Part Two
This continues the previous response. Read More >>> - A Fourth Response - Mr. John Martignoni
Mr. Martignoni responds to Mr. Walker's comments. It is a direct response, rather that injecting his comments into Mr. Walker's e-mail. He does quote from the previous e-mail, however, Mr. Martignoni goes into greater detail and expounds his views in contrast with Mr. Walker's stated beliefs. Read More >>> - Fifth Response - Mr. Walker - Part One
In this portion Mr. Walker responds to Mr. Martignoni's previous e-mail, injecting his comments into Mr. Martignoni's e-mail. Read More >>> - Fifth Response - Mr. Walker - Part Two
This Continues "Fifth Response - Mr. Walker." Read More >>> - A Sixth Response - Mr. John Martignoni
Mr. Martignoni responds to Mr. Walker's previous e-mail on September 5, 2008. Read More >>> - Seventh Response - Mr. Walker - Part One
In this portion Mr. Walker responds to Mr. Martignoni's previous e-mail (Sixth Response) on September 13, 2008. Again, Mr. Walker injects his comments into Mr. Martignoni's e-mail. Read More >>> - Seventh Response - Mr. Walker - Part Two
This continues "Seventh Response - Mr. Walker." Read More >>> - Eigth Response - Mr. John Martignoni
In this response, Mr. John Martignoni responds to Mr. Edward Walker's previous e-mail (Seventh Response). Mr. John Martignoni responds directly to Mr. Walker's comments and quotes rather than injects his comments into Mr. Walker's e-mail. Read More >>> |
|
